Ad Spy Tools Show You the Crime.
Heista Shows You How They Pulled It Off.
Foreplay, MagicBrief, Atria, Motion, AdSpy — every one of them shows you what's winning. None of them shows you why. And none of them builds your version. Here's exactly how they compare.
Get StartedThe Landscape — What Each Tool Actually Does
Every ad creative tool in the market operates in one of three layers:
Layer 1 — SAVE & ORGANIZE
Find winning ads, save them, tag them, share them.
(Foreplay, MagicBrief, Atria, AdSpy)
Layer 2 — ANALYZE PERFORMANCE
Connect your ad accounts. See which of YOUR ads are performing and which elements drive results.
(Motion, MagicBrief, Atria)
Layer 3 — DECODE WHY & GENERATE
Decode the psychological formula behind any winning ad. Build brand strategy from a URL. Generate scripts and images loaded with your brand intelligence from the decoded formula.
(Heista)
Most tools live in Layer 1 and 2. Heista is the only tool that operates in Layer 3.
Full Comparison
Foreplay — $49–$389/mo
What it does well: Clean swipe file organization. 500K+ community-curated ad library. AI search and filtering. Spyder competitor tracking with real-time alerts. Lens creative analytics. Mobile app. Flat-rate pricing regardless of ad spend.
What it added recently: AI script writing, AI storyboards, modular brief builder with custom templates.
Where it stops: Foreplay saves the ad and recently added AI scripting — but the scripts are generated from generic AI, not decoded formulas. No psychological analysis. No brand strategy extraction. No formula-based generation. No gap analysis. You still don’t know WHY the ad you saved actually works.
Best for: Teams that need a clean, well-organized swipe file with team collaboration and basic AI briefs.
MagicBrief — $29–$249/mo
What it does well: Massive AI-searchable library (12M+ ads, 60 attributes). Strong creative analytics synced to ad accounts. Brief builder with storyboarding. Slack integration with automated performance summaries. Competitor tracking.
Where it stops: MagicBrief organizes the workflow and reports on performance — but doesn’t decode psychology. Script generation is AI-assisted, not formula-based. No brand strategy engine. No psychological beat mapping. No gap analysis. Analytics tell you WHAT elements are performing, not the psychological WHY behind them.
Best for: Teams that want creative analytics, workflow organization, and a massive searchable ad library. Especially strong for agencies wanting Slack-integrated performance updates.
Atria — $129–$479/mo
What it does well: Largest ad library in market (25M+ ads). Radar AI scoring trained on $1B+ in ad spend data. Unique review mining feature (NLP on customer reviews → ad concepts). AI ad generation and cloning. Smart asset management with auto-tagging. Competitor tracking for up to 200 brands.
Where it stops: Atria has the most features in the ad spy category — but Radar scores ads on WHAT performs, not WHY psychologically. AI cloning reproduces surface elements, not the underlying formula. No psychological decode. No brand strategy from a URL. No beat-by-beat formula mapping. No gap analysis showing what YOUR brand needs. Limited to Meta and TikTok.
Best for: Teams that want the largest ad library with AI-powered scoring and recommendation. Particularly strong review mining for turning customer feedback into ad concepts.
Minea — $49–$199/mo
What it does well: Product research combined with ad spy for Shopify and D2C brands. Finds winning products and the ads promoting them. Covers Meta, TikTok, Pinterest, and AliExpress ads. Useful for dropshippers and product-first brands looking for what to sell next.
Where it stops: Minea finds what's running — which products are being promoted and which ads are active — but doesn't decode why any of it works. No psychological analysis. No formula extraction. No brand strategy. No generation. It answers "what's selling?" not "why does this ad convert?"
Best for: Shopify and D2C operators who want product research and ad discovery in one tool. Especially strong for identifying trending products and their ad creative.
VidTao — $97–$297/mo
What it does well: YouTube and video ad spy specialist. Tracks video ad spend estimates, landing pages, and media buyers. Deep visibility into long-form video ads and VSLs. Useful for understanding which video ads are spending the most and how long they've been running.
Where it stops: VidTao shows which video ads are spending and for how long — but doesn't decode the formula behind why they convert. No psychological beat mapping. No brand strategy extraction. No script generation from decoded formulas. No gap analysis. It tells you WHO is spending, not WHY their creative works.
Best for: Media buyers and info-product marketers who need YouTube and video ad intelligence. Especially strong for tracking VSL funnels and competitor video spend.
Adbeat — $249+/mo
What it does well: Display and native ad intelligence across major ad networks. Competitive tracking for display campaigns, banner ads, and native placements. Spend estimates and publisher-level data. Useful for understanding competitor display strategies and network allocation.
Where it stops: Adbeat tracks display ad placements, spend, and network distribution — but no psychological analysis of why any creative converts. No formula decode. No brand strategy. No generation. No video analysis. Focused exclusively on display and native, not social or video creative.
Best for: Teams running display and native ad campaigns who need competitive intelligence on placements, publishers, and network spend allocation.
Motion — Free–$349+/mo
What it does well: Best-in-class creative analytics. Beautiful visual reporting. Frame-by-frame video analysis. AI creative tagging. Bridges the gap between media buyers and creative teams. GA4 and Northbeam integrations. $14B+ in ad spend analyzed across 2,100+ teams.
Where it stops: Motion is purely analytics. No ad library for discovery. No swipe file. No creative generation. No scripting. No briefing system. No brand strategy. No formula decode. Motion tells you WHAT is working in your account. It doesn’t decode WHY it works psychologically, and it doesn’t generate what to make next (beyond recommendations).
Best for: Teams spending $25K+/month on ads who need deep creative performance analytics, especially those needing GA4 or Northbeam attribution integration.
AdSpy — $149/mo
What it does well: One of the original ad spy databases. Massive searchable library. Filter by engagement, demographics, text, and landing page.
Where it stops: Dated interface. Facebook and Instagram only. No creative workflow. No analytics beyond search. No AI features. No generation. No collaboration. A legacy tool that hasn’t evolved with the market.
Best for: Solo operators who need a large, searchable Facebook ad database at a flat price.
What None of Them Do
Decode the psychological formula
No tool maps the second-by-second beat sequence, behavioral triggers, persuasion principles, visual strategy, and linguistic architecture of a winning ad. Heista’s PatternMap does this in 30 seconds.
Build brand strategy from a URL
No tool extracts buyer tensions, selling points, brand voice DNA, creative angles, and emotional architecture from your Shopify store or website. Heista’s Brand Strategy does this in 2 minutes.
Generate from proven formulas
No tool generates scripts and images that mirror the decoded psychological architecture of a winning ad, loaded with your specific brand intelligence. Heista’s Creative Director does this in seconds.
Show what’s missing
No tool runs a gap analysis comparing a decoded formula against your brand’s assets to show exactly what you need before creating. Heista’s Gap Analysis does this automatically.
Protect the winning structure
No tool locks the psychological formula while you iterate on voice, tone, selling points, and creative direction. Heista’s Formula Engine does this across every iteration.
Complementary, Not Competitive
Heista doesn't replace your ad library. If you love Foreplay's organization or MagicBrief's analytics or Atria's Radar scoring — keep using them.
Heista adds the layer they're all missing: the WHY and the REBUILD.
Use Foreplay/MagicBrief/Atria to FIND the winning ads.
Use Heista to DECODE why they work.
Use Heista to GENERATE your brand's version.
Or use Heista's own browser extension to heist ads directly from your feed and skip the middle step.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Foreplay | MagicBrief | Atria | Motion | AdSpy | Heista |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ad Library Size | 500K+ | 12M+ | 25M+ | None | Large | Weekly curated + user vault |
| Save Ads (Chrome ext) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ |
| Organize / Tag / Board | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Limited | ✗ | Vault |
| Creative Analytics | ✓ Lens | ✓ Full | ✓ Radar | ✓ Best-in-class | ✗ | Via decode reports |
| Competitor Tracking | ✓ Spyder | ✓ | ✓ (200 brands) | ✓ Brand Intel | Filter | Weekly category reports |
| AI Script Generation | ✓ Generic | ✓ Generic | ✓ Generic | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ Formula-based |
| Psychological Decode | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ PatternMap |
| Brand Strategy from URL | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ Brand Strategy |
| Gap Analysis | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ |
| Formula Protection | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ Formula Engine |
| Image Generation | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ Visual Studio |
| Brand-Loaded Outputs | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ Creative Director |
| Shot List Generation | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ |
| Creative Playbooks | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ |
| Platforms | Meta, TikTok, LinkedIn | Meta, TikTok, Instagram | Meta, TikTok | Meta, TikTok, YouTube, LinkedIn | Facebook, Instagram | Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, FB Ads Library |
| Starting Price | $49/mo | $29/mo | $129/mo | Free (limited) | $149/mo | From $9.99/mo |
Security Footage vs X-Ray Vision
Ad spy tools show you the crime.
Heista shows you how they pulled it off.
They show you the ad. They don't show you the formula. And not one of them generates your version from it.
Ad Spy Tools
You've watched that competitor's ad 50 times.
Screenshotted the hook.
Told your team “make something like this.”
Briefed creators with a reference link and a prayer.
Heista
A question that makes you keep watching
Makes it feel exclusive, then earns trust
Shows the problem, then the fix
Proof specific enough to believe
Frequently Asked Questions
Explore More
Expand what your creative team can do.
Move from brief to better creative work, faster.
7-day free trial.